|
|
TECHNICAL NOTE |
|
|
|
| Year : 2009 | Volume
: 12
| Issue : 3 | Page : 197-200 |
| |
Brain death diagnosis and apnea test safety
Calixto Machado1, Jesus Perez2, Claudio Scherle2, Alejandro Areu2, Alejandro Pando2
1 Institute of Neurology and Neurosurgery, Department of Clinical Neurophysiology, Havana, Cuba
2 Hermanos Ameijeiras Hospital, Service of Neurology, Havana, Cuba
| Date of Submission | 25-Jul-2009 |
| Date of Decision | 27-Aug-2009 |
| Date of Acceptance | 29-Aug-2009 |
| Date of Web Publication | 8-Oct-2009 |
Correspondence Address:
Calixto Machado
Institute of Neurology and Neurosurgery, 29 y D, Vedado, La Habana 10400
Cuba
 Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None  | Check |
DOI: 10.4103/0972-2327.56326
 Abstract | | |
The apnea test is a mandatory examination for determining brain death (BD), because it provides an essential sign of definitive loss of brainstem function. However, several authors have expressed their concern about the safety of this procedure as there are potential complications such as severe hypotension, pneumothorax, excessive hypercarbia, hypoxia, acidosis, and cardiac arrhythmia or asystole. These complications may constrain the examiner to abort the test, thereby compromising BD diagnosis. Nevertheless, when an appropriate oxygen-diffusion procedure is used, this technique is safe. We review here the prerequisites to begin the test, its procedure, potential complications, and the use of alternative ancillary tests. We recommend that the apnea test be retained as a mandatory procedure for the diagnosis of BD. In those situations when the apnea test is terminated by the examiner for some reason or when it is impossible to carry it out in a patient due to the presence of some pathologic condition, alternative ancillary tests should be used to confirm BD.
Keywords: Ancillary tests, apnea test, brain death
How to cite this article:
Machado C, Perez J, Scherle C, Areu A, Pando A. Brain death diagnosis and apnea test safety. Ann Indian Acad Neurol 2009;12:197-200 |
| Introduction | |  |
The apnea test (AT) has been considered by most authors as the 'condition sine qua non' for determining brain death (BD) because it provides an essential sign of a definitive loss of brainstem function. [1],[2],[3],[4],[5],[6],[7] Nonetheless, it is the most difficult clinical test in BD protocols and, besides, is potentially harmful and lengthy. The possible complications of this test include severe hypotension, pneumothorax, excessive hypercarbia, hypoxia, acidosis, and cardiac arrhythmia or asystole. The occurrence of any of these complications may constrain the examiner to abort the test, thereby compromising BD diagnosis. [1],[2],[3],[4],[5],[6],[7] However, when an appropriate oxygen-diffusion procedure is used, this technique is safe. [8],[9],[10],[11],[12],[13],[14],[15],[16] We review here the prerequisites for conducting the test, the procedure, the potential complications, and the use of alternative ancillary tests.
| Prerequisites for the apnea test | | |
It is important to ensure that certain prerequisites are satisfied before the AT is carried out. [14],[15] These are as follows:
The body temperature of the subject needs to be 32C or more. Most authors are of the opinion that this test should not be begun when the body temperature is below 32C. It may be necessary to warm the body to 36C if the body temperature is low. Correction of hypothermia facilitates CO 2 production and reduces the chances of hypotension by stabilizing blood pressure and the hemodynamic state. [17],[18],[19],[20]
The required PaO 2 levels are often not clearly defined; however, it is recommended that preoxygenation with 100% O 2 be done for some time, generally for 10 min, and that hypoxia be avoided. Some experts recommend maintenance of a normal PO 2 or preoxygenation to obtain an arterial PO 2 ≥ 200 mmHg. [12],[19] Preoxygenation helps to avoid possible hypocapnia, which may be due to hyperventilation, or to the setting of high tidal volumes on the mechanical ventilator, or if the patient if hypothermic.
It is important to ensure that the arterial PCO 2 or PaCO 2 is normal or above 40 mmHg. 23 Certain authors recom m end a starting PaCO 2 of 36 mmHg or higher. [21],[22] Others state that the important consideration is to elevate the PaCO2 to 20 mmHg above the starting PaCO2 level. [23]
It is recommended that the blood pH should be normal or in the low basic range before beginning the AT. [24]
A pretest systolic blood pressure of at least 90 mmHg is recommended by the Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology.
Fluid balance: Euvolemia or a positive fluid balance during the previous 6 h [15],[19] is also recommended.
Medication: AT should not be performed when the subject is under the influence of drugs that may paralyze the respiratory muscles, i.e., relaxants such as pancuronium. [25]
| Procedure of the apnea test | | |
Disconnection of the patient from the respirator
If continuous or intermittent oxygen supply is preceded by denitrogenation of blood gases, high PaO 2 levels can be sustained for very long periods of time. [26] Preoxygenation removes alveolar nitrogen stores and facilitates oxygen transport. [27] There are several techniques for ascertaining that there is sufficient oxygenation during AT. [15] The first method is to disconnect the patient from the respirator and to insert a catheter or cannula into the endotracheal tube down to the level of the carina and provide pure oxygen at a rate of 4-10 l/min. This would ensure sufficient alveolar ventilation and transport of oxygen to the blood even without any respiratory movements. [17]
In the second procedure the patient is not disconnected from the respirator but the minute volume is decreased to a very low level (0.5-2 l/min), with the respirator in the synchronized intermittent mandatory volume ventilation mode and with pure oxygen provided for inspiration. In this procedure, the patient is not disconnected until the required PaCO 2 is achieved. Lang and coworkers prefer this method as it prevents tracheopulmonary complications and allows the examiner to detect any spontaneous respiratory effort. [14],[15] Al Jumah et al, have proposed a third procedure of biphasic intermittent positive airway pressure (BIPAP), a method known as 'bulk diffusion'. [28]
Some authors considered it safer to test for apnea by keeping the patient with a continuous flow of 100 % oxygen and low positive end expiratory pressure (PEEP), than to disconnect them from the ventilator. [29],[30]
Duration of the apnea test
Apnea is concluded when no breathing effort is observed at a PaCO 2 of 60 mm Hg or with a 20 mm Hg increment from baseline; this indicates that the AT is positive, thereby supporting the diagnosis of BD. Since a rapid increase in PaCO 2 to 20 mmHg above normal baseline is believed to provide a maximal stimulus to the respiratory centers, such an increase is recommended when the baseline PaCO 2 is at or above 36-40 mmHg. On the other hand, if respiratory movements are detected, the AT is classified as negative (i.e., not supportive of a BD diagnosis), the patient should be reconnected to the respirator. If arterial pressure drops to < 90 mm Hg, or a noticeable desaturation is detected by the oximeter or cardiac arrhythmias occur, the procedure should be stopped immediately and the ventilator should be connected. Some authors do not consider the duration of the AT to be relevant, [15] while others have recommended that the test be stopped after 10-15 min, even if blood gas levels cannot be determined. [25],[31] Under physiological states, the PaCO 2 is predicted to increase by 3-4 mmHg in such situations [32] but this may vary considerably under conditions of brain death. According to some authors it is essential to monitor the blood gases at frequent intervals and the procedure can be extended up to 1 h. [15]
An alternative procedure for the AT has been proposed when a decrease in ventilator volume is not desirable. In this procedure, CO 2 is insufflated to achieve the desired PaCO 2 levels. Lang et al. considered this method to be particularly useful in cases where there is minimal rise in PaCO 2 or when blood oxygenation is hampered by pulmonary problems. [33],[34],[35] This technique requires close monitoring of the patient, but the duration of the procedure could be shortened considerably. [14],[15]
Several authors have estimated the level of PCO 2 at which maximal stimulation of the medullary respiratory centers would occur. Wijdicks has reported the occurrence of a probable unsafe hypercarbia in some cases who had started to breathe at low PCO 2 levels (about 30-35 mm of Hg) but lost respiratory drive some hours later. [10],[36] The same group has also reported that when the ventilator settings are below certain trigger sensitivity thresholds, some patients show false readings of spontaneous respiratory movements at rates of 20-30/min, which may cause confusion in BD determination. [37]
Complications
Several complications can occur during the AT. Goudreau et al, have reported that approximately one in four ATs were associated with cardiovascular complications, and the rate of complications nearly doubled when the tests were carried out without satisfying the prerequisites. Hypotension was the most frequent complication (24%), while cardiac arrhythmia with the potential for ventricular fibrillation or arrest was much less common (1%). A blood pressure reading of 90 mmHg before testing is acceptable as a rule. Usually there is mild increase in blood pressure with hyperoxygenation and marked decrease with hypercapnia. Persistent hypotension may be corrected using intravenous fluids, 5% albumin, or an increase of intravenous dopamine or (nor)epinephrine infusion. [10] It is considered that hypoxemia contributes to cardiac arrhythmia and hypotension during AT. [25] If pulse oximetry is used, saturation values should not drop below 80% as hypoxemia can lead to cardiac arrhythmia or hypotension during AT. [25] There are no precise standards for the blood pH, although pH values less than 7.2 or 7.0 should be avoided although there are reports of safe conduct of the test in spite of very low blood pH values. [38],[39] Low pH of blood is highly correlated with raised PaCO 2 and it is rapidly restored with normoventilation or mild hyperventilation. Normalization of blood pH by administration of buffer or alkaline solutions should be avoided as it could lead to alkalosis when normal ventilation is resumed.
Saposnik et al, reported complications in more than two-thirds of their patients. These complications included hypotension (12%), acidosis (68%), and hypoxemia (23%). They reported that four patients suffered major complications (e.g., pneumothorax). [40] Barotrauma is another complication that has been reported following AT. [41],[42],[43],[44]
Coimbra directly critiqued the use of AT, considering that it may induce potentially irreversible collapse of intracranial vessels by simultaneously worsening intracranial hypertension and inducing hypotension in brain-dead patients. This author remarked that "apnea testing may induce rather than diagnose irreversible brain damage". [40] This argument has been rejected by other authors, because "It has never been demonstrated that global cerebral ischemic penumbra is transformed into global brain infarction by AT," suggesting future studies using serial PET assessments. [24]
Is the apnea test safe in BD diagnosis?
Most authors are of the opinion that in spite of the potential complications, the AT is safe when performed after appropriate oxygen-diffusion procedures. [8],[9],[10],[11],[12],[13],[14],[15],[16] In the rare situations where AT cannot be carried out, other ancillary tests may be required. [14],[15],[33],[34],[35],[45]
In a large series of 228 BD determinations, with a special emphasis on the AT, it was observed that in 7% instances the physician decided not to administer the AT because of hemodynamic instability or poor oxygenation at baseline, and in 3% cases the test had to be terminated due to hypotension or hypoxemia. [46] In a previous study, hypotension occurred in 24% of ATs. It is not clear if there was an overlap of these two series, because the first study was carried out from 1990 to 1999 [10] and the second one from 1996 to 2007. [46]
Alternative ancillary tests
The AT test may have to be abandoned if the patient has significant hemodynamic instability, poor PaO 2 at baseline despite adequate preoxygenation, or inability to achieve target PaCO 2 levels. Extensive thoracic trauma or significant pulmonary disorders interfering with ventilation are other conditions that may prevent the use of the AT. [1],[2],[3],[4],[5],[6],[7] Estimation of cerebral blood flow by transcranial Doppler studies or CT angiography can be considered when the AT cannot be carried out. Other ancillary tests that may be used to confirm brain death include multimodality evoked potential studies and the atropine test. [47],[48],[49],[50],[51],[52],[53],[54],[55],[56]
| Conclusion | | |
With this study conducted in Cuba, we have arrived at the same conclusion as other authors, i.e., that in all cases in which the AT had to be aborted due to progressive hypotension or hypoxemia, there had been a nonsatisfactory preoxygenation technique. [8],[9],[10],[11],[12],[13],[14],[15],[16]
As this test provides an essential sign of a definitive loss of brainstem functions, we recommend that it be retained as a mandatory test in the diagnostic criteria for BD. In those situations when it is aborted by the examiner for some reason or when it is impossible to apply the test in a patient due to certain pathologic conditions, alternative ancillary tests should be used to confirm BD. [47],[48],[49],[50],[51],[52],[53],[54],[55],[56]
| References | | |
| 1. | Tsai WH, Lee WT, Hung KL. Determination of brain death in children: A medical center experience. Acta Paediatr Taiwan 2005;46:132-7.  [PUBMED] |
| 2. | Okuyaz C, Gucuyener K, Karabacak NI, Aydin K, Serdaroglu A, Cingi E. Tc-99m-HMPAO SPECT in the diagnosis of brain death in children. Pediatr Int 2004;46:711-4. |
| 3. | Ashwal S. Clinical diagnosis and confirmatory testing of brain death in children. In: Wijdicks EF, editor. Brain death. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins; 2001. p. 91-114. |
| 4. | Mejia RE, Pollack MM. Variability in brain death determination practices in children. JAMA 1995;274:550-3. [PUBMED] |
| 5. | Paret G, Barzilay Z. Apnea testing in suspected brain dead children-physiological and mathematical modelling. Intensive Care Med 1995;21:247-52. [PUBMED] |
| 6. | Chantarojanasiri T, Preutthipan A. Apnea documentation for determination of brain death in Thai children. J Med Assoc Thai 1993;76:165-8. [PUBMED] |
| 7. | Galaske RG, Schober O, Heyer R. Determination of brain death in children with 123I-IMP and Tc-99m HMPAO. Psychiatry Res 1989;29:343-5. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 8. | Wijdicks EF. In search of a safe apnea test in brain-death: Is the procedure really more dangerous than we think. Arch Neurol 1995;52:338. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 9. | Goudreau JL, Wijdicks EF, Emery S. How safe is apnea testing? An audit of 124 procedures. Neurology 1999;52:A511. |
| 10. | Goudreau JL, Wijdicks EF, Emery SF. Complications during apnea testing in the determination of brain death: Predisposing factors. Neurology 2000;55:1045-8. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 11. | Wijdicks EF. Brain death worldwide: Accepted fact but no global consensus in diagnostic criteria. Neurology 2002;58:20-5. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 12. | Wijdicks EF, Rabinstein AA, Manno EM, Atkinson JD. Pronouncing brain death - Contemporary practice and safety of the apnea test. Neurology 2008;71:1240-4. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 13. | Provisional recommendations of the French Language Society of Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurology Committee assigned to study the E.E.G. signs of 'cerebral death'. Rev Neurol (Paris) 1969;121:237-8. |
| 14. | Lang CJ, Heckmann JG. How should testing for apnea be performed in diagnosing brain death? Adv Exp Med Biol 2004,550:169-74. [PUBMED] |
| 15. | Lang CJ, Heckmann JG. Apnea testing for the diagnosis of brain death. Acta Neurol Scand 2005;112:358-69. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 16. | Vivien B, Amour J, Nicolas-Robin A, Vesque M, Langeron O, Coriat P, et al. An evaluation of capnography monitoring during the apnoea test in brain-dead patients. Eur J Anaesthesiol 2007;24:868-75. [PUBMED] |
| 17. | Wijdicks EF. Clinical diagnosis and confirmatory testing in brain death in adults. In: Wijdicks EF, editor. Brain death. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins; 2001. p. 61-90. |
| 18. | Maekawa T, Sadamitsu D, Tateishi A. Safety applications in apnea test. Rinsho Shinkeigaku 1993;33:1331-3. [PUBMED] |
| 19. | Wijdicks EF. Determining brain death in adults. Neurology 1995;45:1003-11. [PUBMED] |
| 20. | Dominguez-Roldan JM, Barrera-Chacon JM, Murillo-Cabezas F, Santamaria-Mifsut JL, Rivera-Fernandez V. Clinical factors influencing the increment of blood carbon dioxide during the apnea test for the diagnosis of brain death. Transplant Proc 1999;31:2599-600. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 21. | Belsh JM, Schiffman PL. Apnoea testing to confirm brain death in clinical practice. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1987;50:649-50. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 22. | Belsh JM, Blatt R, Schiffman PL. Apnea testing in brain death. Arch Intern Med 1986;146:2385-8. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 23. | Telleria-Diaz A. Apnea testing to establish death based on brain criteria. Rev Neurol 1998;155:108-10. |
| 24. | Lang CJ, Heckmann JG. Apnea testing for the diagnosis of brain death. Acta Neurol Scand 2005;112:358-69. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 25. | Ropper AH, Kennedy SK, Russell L. Apnea testing in the diagnosis of brain death: Clinical and physiological observations. J Neurosurg 1981;55:942-6. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 26. | Ropper AH, Kennedy SK, Russell L. Apnea testing in the diagnosis of brain death: Clinical and physiological observations. J Neurosurg 1981;55:942-6. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 27. | Goudreau JL, Emery SF, Wijdicks EF. Complications during apnea testing in the determination of brain death: Predisposing factors. Neurology 2001;56:1249. |
| 28. | al Jumah M, McLean DR, al Rajeh S, Crow N. Bulk diffusion apnea test in the diagnosis of brain death. Crit Care Med 1992;20:1564-7. |
| 29. | Perel A. Apnea tests for brain death. Arch Neurol 1991;48:1215-6. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 30. | Perel A, Berger M, Cotev S. The use of continuous flow of oxygen and PEEP during apnea in the diagnosis of brain death. Intensive Care Med 1983;9:25-7. [PUBMED] |
| 31. | Earnest MP, Beresford HR, McIntyre HB. Testing for apnea in suspected brain death: Methods used by 129 clinicians. Neurology 1986;36:542-4. [PUBMED] |
| 32. | Shapiro BA. The apnea-PaCO2 relationship: Some clinical and medico-legal considerations. J Clin Anesth 1989;1:323-7. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 33. | Lang CJ. Apnea testing guided by continuous transcutaneous monitoring of partial pressure of carbon dioxide. Crit Care Med 1998;26:868-72. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 34. | Lang CJ. Blood pressure and heart rate changes during apnoea testing with or without CO2 insufflation. Intensive Care Med 1997;8:903-7. |
| 35. | Lang CJ. Apnea testing by artificial CO2 augmentation. Neurology 1995;45:966-9. [PUBMED] |
| 36. | Wijdicks EF. In search of a safe apnea test in brain death: Is the procedure really more dangerous than we think? Arch Neurol 1995;52:338-9. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 37. | Wijdicks EF, Manno EM, Holets SR. Ventilator self-cycling may falsely suggest patient effort during brain death determination. Neurology 2005;65:774. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 38. | Rowland TW, Donnelly JH, Jackson AH. Apnea documentation for determination of brain death in children. Pediatrics 1984;74:505-8. [PUBMED] |
| 39. | Brilli RJ, Bigos D. Apnea threshold and pediatric brain death. Crit Care Med 2000;28:1257. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 40. | Coimbra CG. Implications of ischemic penumbra for the diagnosis of brain death. Braz J Med Biol Res 1999;32:1479-87. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 41. | Saposnik G, Rizzo G, Vega A, Sabbatiello R, Deluca JL. Problems associated with the apnea test in the diagnosis of brain death. Neurol India 2004;52:342-5. [PUBMED]  |
| 42. | Seshia S, Teitelbaum J, Young B. Response to Lessard et al. Can J Neurol Sci 2000;27:353-4. |
| 43. | Lessard M, Mallais R, Turmel A. Apnea test in the diagnosis of brain death. Can J Neurol Sci 2000;27:353-4. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 44. | Brandstetter RD, Choi MY, Mallepalli VN, Klass S. An unusual cause of pulmonary barotrauma during apneic oxygenation testing. Heart Lung 1994;23:88-9. [PUBMED] |
| 45. | Lang CJ, Heckmann JG, Erbguth F, Druschky A, Haslbeck M, Reinhardt F, et al. Transcutaneous and intra-arterial blood gas monitoring: A comparison during apnoea testing for the determination of brain death. Eur J Emerg Med 2002;9:51-6. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 46. | Wijdicks EF, Pfeifer EA. Neuropathology of brain death in the modern transplant era. Neurology 2008;70:1234-7. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 47. | Machado C, Natl Commission, Certification D. Resolution for the determination and certification of death in Cuba. Revista de Neurologia 2003;36:763-70. |
| 48. | Machado C, Abeledo M, Alvarez C, Aroche RM, Barrios I, Lasanta AM, et al. Cuba has passed a law for the determination and certification of death. Adv Exp Med Biol 2004;550:139-42. [PUBMED] |
| 49. | Machado C. Determination of death. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2005;49:592-3. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 50. | Machado C. Variability of brain death determination guidelines in leading US neurologic institutions. Neurology 2008;71:1125. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| 51. | Machado C, Valdes P, Garcia-Tigera J, Virues T, Biscay R, Miranda J, et al. Brain-stem auditory evoked-potentials and brain-death. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1991;80:392-8. |
| 52. | Machado C, Garcνa-Tigera J, Coutin P. Multimodality evoked potentials and electroretinography in a test battery for the early diagnosis of brain death. Electroenceph Clin Neurophysiol 1991;79:S19. |
| 53. | Machado C, Santiesteban R, Garcia O, Coutin P, Beurgo MA, Romαn J, et al. Visual-evoked potentials and electroretinography in brain-dead patients. Doc Ophthalmol 1993;84:89-96. |
| 54. | Machado C, Valdes P, Garcia O, Coutin P, Miranda J, Roman J. Short latency somatosensory evoked potentials in brain-dead patients using restricted low cut filter setting. J Neurosurg Sci 1993;37:133-40. |
| 55. | Facco E, Machado C. Evoked potentials in the diagnosis of brain death. In: Machado C, Shewmon DL, editors. Brain death and disorders of consciousness. 50 vol. New York: Kluwer Academics/Plenum Publishers; 2004. p. 1-268. |
| 56. | Machado C. Evoked potentials in brain death. Clin Neurophysiol 2004;115:238-9. [PUBMED] [FULLTEXT] |
| This article has been cited by | | 1 |
Brain death: a clinical overview |
|
| William Spears, Asim Mian, David Greer | | Journal of Intensive Care. 2022; 10(1) | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 2 |
Jahi McMath, a New Disorder of Consciousness |
|
| Calixto Machado | | Revista Latinoamericana de Bioética. 2021; 21(1): 137 | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 3 |
Apnea Testing for the Determination of Brain Death: A Systematic Scoping Review |
|
| Katharina M. Busl, Ariane Lewis, Panayiotis N. Varelas | | Neurocritical Care. 2021; 34(2): 608 | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 4 |
Brain Death and Organ Donation
|
|
| Suchita Kosare, Apeksha A Gala | | Journal of Research & Innovation in Anesthesia. 2020; 4(2): 45 | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 5 |
Brain death and care of the organ donor |
|
| Lakshmi Kumar | | Journal of Anaesthesiology Clinical Pharmacology. 2016; 32(2): 146 | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 6 |
result 2 Document Apnea testing during brain death assessment: A review of clinical practice and published literature |
|
| Brady Scott, J., Gentile, M.A., Bennett, S.N., Couture, M., MacIntyre, N.R. | | Respiratory Care. 2013; | | [Pubmed] | | | 7 |
The degree of certainty in brain death: probability in clinical and Islamic legal discourse |
|
| Faisal Qazi,Joshua C. Ewell,Ayla Munawar,Usman Asrar,Nadir Khan | | Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics. 2013; 34(2): 117 | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
