Gas geyser syndrome: An important preventable cause of disabling neurological events

Pamela Correia; Chandrashekhar Agrawal; Rajeev Ranjan


Users Online: 1169	Home \| About the Journal \| Instructions \| Current Issue \| Back Issues \| Login



CASE REPORT

Year : 2013 \| Volume : 16 \| Issue : 2 \| Page : 245-248

Gas geyser syndrome: An important preventable cause of disabling neurological events

Pamela Correia, Chandrashekhar Agrawal, Rajeev Ranjan
Department of Neurology, Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, New Delhi, India

Date of Submission	25-Mar-2012
Date of Decision	08-Apr-2012
Date of Acceptance	10-Jun-2012
Date of Web Publication	24-May-2013

Correspondence Address:
Pamela Correia
Neurology Office 4th Floor, Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, Rajinder Nagar, New Delhi-100 060
India

Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None

Check

PMID: 23956574

Abstract

To bring to light the greatly hazardous effects of the use of flue less gas geysers in the domestic setting. Over a period of two years (2008 to 2010) twenty six cases were documented as presenting with unexplained neurological events while bathing in an ill ventilated bathroom with a functional flue less gas geyser. The cases were mainly of three distinct prototypes namely seizure like episodes seen in 11 patients, carbon monoxide intoxication in 13 patients with near cardiac arrest in 4, and as a precipitating factor for epilepsy as seen in 2 cases. Out of the 13 cases presenting as carbon monoxide intoxication 4 had subtle cognitive defects and 2 developed early Parkinsonian features on follow up. To increase awareness regarding gas geyser induced epilepsy and associated carbon monoxide intoxication, both of which are entirely preventable conditions. We also wish to emphasize the importance of stringent and universal implementation of gas geyser usage and installation laws.

Keywords: Carbon monoxide, epilepsy, gas geyser

How to cite this article:
Correia P, Agrawal C, Ranjan R. Gas geyser syndrome: An important preventable cause of disabling neurological events. Ann Indian Acad Neurol 2013;16:245-8

How to cite this URL:
Correia P, Agrawal C, Ranjan R. Gas geyser syndrome: An important preventable cause of disabling neurological events. Ann Indian Acad Neurol [serial online] 2013 [cited 2021 Mar 3];16:245-8. Available from: https://www.annalsofian.org/text.asp?2013/16/2/245/112482

Introduction

Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG) geysers are deployed very frequently for heating water due to the perennial problem of erratic electrical supply in many areas in India. This simple and economical device, used on a daily basis in many Indian households may cause certain significantly disabling neurological events.

Sudden loss of consciousness in the bathroom can be due to a number of causes like seizures, head injury, stroke, cardiac events, syncopal episodes, due to various poisonings and toxin exposures. ^[1] Such an episode is highly distressing and may have long lasting or even life threatening after effects.

We report 26 such cases of unexplained neurological collapse in the bathroom presenting as seizure like episodes, carbon monoxide intoxication and as a precipitating factor for epilepsy. The possible attributable cause for these events could be exposure to high amounts of various toxic gases, mainly carbon monoxide (CO) released due to incomplete combustion of LPG in gas geysers in small ill ventilated bathrooms in homes. Increased awareness of gas geyser induced epilepsy and associated CO intoxication can go a long way in the prevention of these entities.

Case Reports

Twenty six cases of predominantly three distinct prototypes, as described below, were observed over three years from 2008 to 2011 in Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, New Delhi.

The three distinct prototypes noted were - 1) Seizure like episodes seen in 11 patients, 2) Carbon monoxide intoxication in 13 patients with near cardiac arrest in 4, and 3) A precipitating factor for epilepsy as seen in 2 cases. This separation is based on the presenting features. It is of course accepted that the seizures in group 1 were due to Carbon monoxide intoxication, and the patients in group 2 may have had a seizure which was not noted.

A single case from each of the three groups observed is described below:

Group 1: Seizure like episode

A 38 year old female had a sudden spell of extreme vertigo while bathing with hot water from a gas geyser, when she had been in the bathroom, which was small (4 ΄× 6) and with a single shut window, for about 30 minutes. She felt very weak and was unable to open the bathroom door by herself. She was later found in an unconscious condition on the bathroom floor with some frothing from the mouth. Her vital signs were normal and she regained complete consciousness in about an hour without evidence of any neurological deficit. Her MRI brain as well as MR Angiogram was normal. All other routine blood tests, ECG and EEG were normal. She returned after a week with similar symptoms. She was advised to discontinue the flue less gas geyser usage. This has solved her problem till date.

Group 2: Carbon Monoxide Intoxication

A 23 year old engineer was found in an unconscious state in the bathroom without any associated frothing at mouth, tongue bite or incontinence. He was not responding to verbal commands, pupils were semi dilated and sluggishly reacting. He had marked hypotension (BP 80/40) and required ventilatory support. Blood gas analysis revealed elevated pC02. Routine blood tests, ECG and EEG were normal.

MRI of the brain, which could be done only later in the second week of illness, revealed areas of altered signal intensity in bilateral globus pallidi [Figure 1]. The globus pallidal lesions were bilaterally symmetrical, appeared mildly hypo intense on T1 and hyper intense on T2 images. He later developed memory deficits and early parkinsonian features. He had recently installed a gas geyser in the bathroom which was functional at the time of the incident. This event has had a lasting negative impact on both his personal and professional life.

Figure 1: Axial T2-weighted MRI of Brain at the level of Basal ganglia showing hyper intense lesions involving bilateral globus pallidi

Click here to view

Group 3: Trigger factor for Epilepsy

A 14 year old male child was found unconscious on the bathroom floor with some frothing from the mouth. He was taken to a nearby hospital where he was treated for a probable seizure. A MRI brain was done which was normal. An EEG revealed spike discharges in anterior leads. All the routine blood and biochemical tests were normal. He had no history of any previous seizure episode or head injury. There was no family history of epilepsy.

He reported again with a convulsive episode while he was at school after a few weeks. At present he is seizure free for about a year and on regular antiepileptic medications. The family would routinely use a gas geyser which was functional at the time of the episode. The geyser has now been reinstalled in their balcony, which is well ventilated. No such incidents have occurred again with any other family members using it.

In all the 26 such cases recorded, consciousness was altered only transiently. There were 15 males and 11 females in the age group of 14 to 46 years. 17 cases were from semi-urban areas while 9 cases were from a rural setting. Out of the 13 cases presenting as carbon monoxide intoxication 4 had subtle cognitive defects and 2 developed early Parkinsonian features on follow up.

Discussion

All the twenty six cases recorded have an uncanny similarity in terms of the setting of the event that is in a small ill-ventilated bathroom with a functional gas geyser at the time of the episode. All these events were usually in winter months and in young to middle aged individuals without any significant risk factors. Also all the patients regained normal consciousness very fast and made an excellent neurological recovery except for 2 patients of carbon monoxide intoxication who developed early Parkinsonian features. None of the patients had a previous history of seizure, stroke, head injury, any cardiovascular risk factor for syncope or any panic attack. Hence the evidence, though not infallible, gives a strong suggestion that the root cause of these events could lie in the usage of gas geysers.

The domestic use of gas geysers for supply of hot water in bathrooms and kitchens has been on the rise due to its cheap initial installation and non requirement of electricity. However, LPG gas geysers if not installed and used in the recommended conditions can have hazardous and sometimes fatal effects.

Incomplete combustion of LPG due to inadequate ventilation leads to accumulation of mainly carbon monoxide and nitrous oxide. Clinical features of acute carbon monoxide poisoning include headache, dizziness and confusion. ^[2] Coma or seizures can occur in patients with prolonged exposure. ^[3]

Magnetic resonance imaging is the modality of choice for suspected CO poisoning seen as symmetrical T2 hyper intensities in the basal ganglia. ^[4] However, only symmetrical affection of the globus pallidus may also be seen. ^[5]

Depending on the type of flue (vent) system used gas geysers are of three main types:

Room sealed (balanced flue)
External flue

Flue less (Room-sealed (balanced-flue) gas water heaters are the first choice for new installation. Fresh air for combustion and combustion products are taken from and discharged directly to outside air, without contaminating room air.

Flue less gas water heaters are considered dangerous if used to supply hot water to a bath or shower, because the products of combustion containing CO, discharge directly into the room, and may build up to dangerous levels. They are now obsolete in Hong Kong and the ordinance specifies that even a flue less (sink) gas water heater for the kitchen must provide a warning label: Do not use for more than 5 minutes continuously, ^[6] In the United Kingdom the gas safety (installation and use) regulations have prescribed specific criteria of ventilation for flue less gas appliances. ^[7] [Table 1]. Canada recommends against the use of flue less gas appliances because they can "pose a serious health and safety risk to the occupants." ^[8]

Table 1: Ventilation for flueless gas appliances

Click here to view

There have been numerous studies on flue less gas heaters used in various settings which reveal that these heaters emit numerous combustion products including Nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide, carbon monoxide and formaldehyde [Table 2]. In conclusion a common phenomenon observed was that pollutants released by flue less gas heaters were often higher than the stipulated guideline levels, especially when the heaters are operated at low gas pressure. This also suggests that flue less gas heaters are potentially vulnerable to incorrect installation, misuse and disrepair.

Table 2: Summary of studies on pollutants released from Flueless Gas Heaters

Click here to view

In Australia as per the Gas installation manual rules all flue less gas appliances have to be labeled with the following wordings: ^[15]

Do not operate this appliance before reading the instruction (user guide) booklet.
Do not place articles on or against this appliance.
Do not store chemicals or flammable materials, or spray aerosols near this appliance.
Do not operate with panels, covers or guards removed from this appliance.
Do not operate in a bathroom or bedroom.
Do not operate in an unventilated room.
Do not operate in a room with volume less than (a value dependent on heater capacity).
Emissions from this space heater may affect persons susceptible to respiratory problems.

Conclusion

The key objective of this article is to increase awareness regarding gas geyser induced epilepsy and associated carbon monoxide intoxication, both of which are entirely preventable conditions.

Flue less gas geysers are proving to be the 'modern day gas chambers' with the stark contrast that these geysers are installed willingly and in good faith by innocent consumers.

We also wish to make an effort towards the implementation of stringent policies for gas geyser installations in India or any other place where these gas appliance installation laws are being freely flouted or are not existent.

Acknowledgments

No grants or funds from government or private agencies have been used in this study. We confirm that we have read the Journal's position on issues involved in ethical publication and affirm that this report is consistent with those guidelines.

References

1.	Singh P, Lamba A, Bansal R, Singh G. Unexplained neurological events during bathing in young people: Possible association with the use of gas geysers. Ann Indian Acad Neurol 2008;11:103-5. [PUBMED]
2.	Mehta SR, Das S, Singh SK, Carbon monoxide poisoning. MJAFI 2007;63:362-5.( Medical Journal Armed Forces India )
3.	Ely EW, Moorehead B, Haponik EF. Warehouse worker′s headache: Emergency evaluation and management of 30 patients with carbon monoxide poisoning. Am J Med 1995;98:145-55.
4.	O′Donnel P, Buxton PJ, Pitkin A, Jarvis LJ. Magnetic resonance imaging appearances of brain in acute carbon monoxide poisoning. Clin Radiol 2000;55:273-80.
5.	Subhashchandra S, Jatishwor W, Suraj T. Isolated symmetrical bilateral basal ganglia T2 hyper intensity in carbon monoxide poisoning. Ann Indian Acad Neurol 2008;11:251-3.
6.	Know more about gas safety. Domestic Gas Appliance Safety. Available from: www.ab.ust.hk/hseo/pdf/gass.PDF. [Last accessed on 2011 May 24].
7.	Additional provisions for gas burning appliances with a rated input up to 70 kW (net), Gas safety (Installation and use) Regulations. DocumentJ; Section 3:36-40. Available from: www.documentj.co.uk. [Last accessed on 2011 May 24].
8.	DNR (Department of Natural Resources, Canada) (2004). Office of energy efficiency. Available from: http://oee.nrcan.gc.ca/english/r2000_standard_mechsys.cfm? PrintView=N&Text=N. [Last Accessed on 2011 May 24].
9.	Brown SK, Mahoney KJ, Cheng M. Room chamber assessment of pollutant emission properties of (nominally) low-emission unflued gas heaters. Indoor Air 2004;14 (Supp 8):84-91. (checked accuracy in pubmed)
10.	Pilotto LS, Nitschke M, Smith BJ, Pisaniello D, Ruffin RE, McElroy HJ, et al. Randomized controlled trial of unflued gas heater replacement on respiratory health of asthmatic school children. Int J Epidemiol 2004;33:208-14.
11.	Sheppeard V, Corbett SJ, Morgan G. Indoor air pollution in New South Wales. In: Proceedings of the 16th International Clean Air and Environment Conference. Christchurch, New Zealand: 2002. p. 19-23.( Clean Air Society of Australia and New Zealand)
12.	AWN Consultants and Team Ferrari Environmental. Technical report No. 9: Unflued gas appliances and air quality in Australian Homes. Canberra: Department of the Environment and Heritage; 2004. Available from: http://www.deh.gov.au/atmosphere/airtoxics/report9. [Last accessed on 2011 May 24].
13.	HSE (Health and Safety Executive). Flue less gas fires - concentration of carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide and nitrogen dioxide, and particulate level produced in use. Research Report 23. 2004. Available from: http://www.hse.gov.uk/research/rrhtm/rr023.htm. [Last accessed on 2011 May 24].
14.	Kingham, Petrovic N. Turning up the heat! Nitrogen dioxide in Nelson homes, New Zealand. Clean Air and Environmental Quality 2005;39:34-40.(Reference is quoted in the same manner in the publication by Commonwealth of Australia 2007. No other abbreviation of the journal name is stated)
15.	The health effects of unflued gas heater use in Australia. Available from: www.health.gov.au:en health (PDF 583kb). [Last accessed on 2012 May 1].